Why is Drew Brees a stud and Joey Harrington a dud? Why is
Peyton Manning a four-time MVP and JaMarcus Russell a benchwarmer? All of these
NFL quarterbacks have the physical tools—arm strength, accuracy, footwork—necessary
to play professional football, you’d imagine, or else they would have never
even made it to the big leagues. But their performance on the field is a
The difference between elite quarterbacks and highly-touted but
dismally performing prospects, it turns out, may not be in their muscles, but
rather in the organs between their ears.
According to an
article in The Times-Picayune, there is a growing interest in studying the
brains and cognitive abilities of NFL quarterbacks. Why not? Quarterbacking is
the most mentally challenging position in football, and teams would love to
know if it is possible to determine which players simply don’t have the thinking
skills required to succeed at a high level—before
the draft and salary negotiation.
But wait, this is just football, you might say; it’s not
like it’s rocket science. Well, on that last point, you may be right—football
may be harder, in some ways, mentally
The article points out all of the things that a quarterback
has to process. He must learn all 130 or so of his team’s offensive plays—and not
just his role, but those of his 10 teammates (and if these guys are anything
like my high school teammates, they’ll often forget where they’re supposed to
go). He has to spend about 25 hours a week studying film to prep for the next
opponent. And he needs to incorporate and adapt all of this information upon
taking the field and gauging the defensive alignment—with only about 30 seconds
of huddle time to decide.
Once the ball is snapped, things get even more hectic.
Whether a receiver gets bumped, a defensive back shades to a particular side of
the field, or a defensive lineman breaks through into the backfield, a QB is
left with approximately 3.5 seconds to make a final choice on where and when to
release the ball.
According to the article, football experts and neuroscientists
have been discussing the possibility that guys like Brees (of the New Orleans
Saints) and Manning (of the Indianapolis Colts), who were first and second,
respectively, in the league in touchdown passes this season, excel because of
exceptional performance in specific regions of their brains.
Some neuroscientists believe that top-notch QBs are
particularly adept at “unconscious” thought. Their minds intuitively process things
in a split second, without them ever really “thinking” about it, enabling these
players to make correct assessments even during a fast-paced game.
If you are a fast typist, you also understand unconscious
thought, also known as implicit memory: Study the keys long enough, practice
hard, and at some point you can type without looking or actively thinking about
what you are doing. But it is far more vital on the football field. Even if you
or I studied film obsessively and had a knack for throwing spirals, we probably
wouldn’t be able to process the moving defense in a matter of seconds like
these top QBs. The same appears to be true for non-performers like Russell, the
Oakland Raiders former top draft pick, and Harrington, who the Detroit Lions
took with the third pick in 2002.
No doubt the NFL and neuroscientists will continue to team
up in hopes of discovering what to look for in quarterbacks’ brains. It’s
already been suggested that the orbital frontal cortex handles implicit memory,
so further analysis on that region of the brain could provide answers.
For now, fans of the Minnesota Vikings and New York Jets,
the respective opponents of the Saints and Colts this Sunday, will have to hope
that Brees and Manning are taken down before they even have 3.5 seconds to make
a decision. If they are given enough time, however, Super Bowl XLIV may be known
as the Braniac Bowl.