Is Gender Hard-Wired in Our Brains?

Men and women are obviously born physically different, but are our brains hard-wired to display masculine and feminine traits? Wednesday’s SciCafé event, “How the Brain Shows its Feminine Side,” at the American Museum of Natural History in New York City, explored this question.

Continue reading

Abigail Baird Talks Adolescent Decision-Making With Vassar “Friend”

At Vassar’s inaugural “At the Pub” event, Vassar alums Lisa Kudrow, of “Friends” fame, and Abigail Baird, Ph.D., a professor of psychology at her alma mater, settled in for a public conversation about the ever-intriguing teenage brain.

“The first important thing is that there is something happening—it’s there and it’s growing,” quipped Baird, a Dana Alliance for Brain Initiatives member.

Over the course of the hour-long event, Baird discussed the different parts of the brain and how they process information and affect decision-making during the teenage years. She also talked about gender roles and how that area of study has become more interesting in recent years.

“One of the most amazing things about human development, and particularly about brain development, [is] the reason it waits is so that you can be anything that the culture needs or that is demanded of you,” said Baird. “We’ve been asking males to be more sensitive, and guess what? They are.”

Watch the complete video of the event below.

And keep an eye out for our new briefing paper on the teenage brain (in which Baird addresses adolescent risk-taking), which will be posted on our homepage in the next few weeks.

–Ann L. Whitman

Sex and Brain Science

Is the study of sex differences gaining traction in neuroscience? It was the topic of the very first Social Issues Roundtable at the Society for Neuroscience, in 1983, and it was the topic again this year. Thirty years ago, it didn't seem to affect the crowd, though—research continued to focus on males (usually excluding females, whose additional monthly cycles were sometimes thought to dirty the results and be too complicated to take into account).

But now, "I'm starting to believe we've hit some sort of critical mass in the past decade," said Larry Cahill of the University of California, Irvine. "I think it's going to start changing rapidly."

Cahill is in a position to know. He's been talking about sex differences in research for decades, often to deaf ears, he said. Sex differences in the brain are real, and critically important, but news and information about them often gets misinterpreted. Media and careless people often overgeneralize from close studies to the greater population, to the point where "male brains" and "female brains" can seem different species.

Cahill said he has heard people who would never generalize the results of male-only rat studies to female rats, then go on and generalize them to people—both men and women.

In terms of behavior research, too, "there is a tendency for people to light up all their gender schemas," said Melissa Hines of Cambridge University. Just because non-human mammals show sex-typed preferences when they play with toys doesn't mean human boys are doomed to a truck-fixation, for example. Data from people who have gender identity disorder suggests that people are affected by hormones, but also how they are raised and where they were raised (and when—pink was considered the "boy" color in the U.S. 100 years ago).

Nevertheless, "there are sex differences at all levels of brain function… down to the molecular level," Cahill said. For example, a manner of apoptosis (how cells die and are cleared away) differs by sex. Another recent robust finding is in how emotional memories are processed. "It's just ubiquitous in brain science," he said.

Different also does not mean unequal, Cahill argued. For example, would you say "2 plus 3" does not equal the very different "10 minus 5"? Male and female brains certainly have some differences, but the results they produce, in cognition and behavior, may well be equivalent.

"If two populations are different and you want to treat them equally, you may have to treat them differently," Cahill said.

"I'm also against the misconceptions at this meeting, and I know about them because I shared them," Cahill said. It is not too hard to take sex differences into account when planning research—all research takes differences into account. And it doesn't always make things more complicated: "I am unaware that the average effect size in sex difference research is any different than any other area of brain reseach," he said

"The real peril… is that people will continue not to study sex differences. For me, it means the burden of proof has shifted. It's up to you to justify why you're not taking it into acount," he told the scientists in the room.

Searching the SfN database for posters, workshops, and sessions including the term "sex+difference," I got more than 150 hits, including sessions on neural development, immunity, stress, memory, antidepressant response, and obesity. On the other hand, there were more than 16,000 posters and sessions presented during the meeting.

Also speaking during the roundtable were Janet Hyde of the University of Wisconsin and  Maryjane Wraga of Smith College; the event was organized by Lise Eliot of Chicago Medical School of Rosalind Franklin University of Medicine and Science. I had to leave for another lecture halfway through the roundtable's Q&A session, but I heard later it got a bit heated (see more on Slate and at Psychneuro's blog). 

–Nicky Penttila

%d bloggers like this: